How to Structure a Good-Better-Best Pricing Tier That Naturally Drives Upsell and Expansion Revenue

As a SaaS founder, you’ve poured everything into building a product that solves a real problem. But let me ask you a question: how much time have you spent architecting your pricing page?


For most early-stage companies, the answer is "not enough." The first pricing page is often a mix of guesswork, a quick look at competitors, and a desire not to scare anyone away. The result is often a single, flat price or a confusing list of features that leaves money on the table.


Here’s the hard truth I've learned from over 15 years in this industry: Your initial pricing is a growth ceiling. To break through it, you need to stop thinking of your pricing as a simple list and start treating it as a product in itself—a product designed to drive revenue growth.


The most powerful tool for this is a strategic "Good-Better-Best" tiering model. When done right, it’s not just a set of options; it’s a revenue escalator that builds expansion revenue—the lifeblood of a healthy SaaS business—directly into your model.


The Strategic "Job" of Each Tier


The trap most founders fall into is thinking of tiers as just different buckets of features. A strategic approach assigns a specific "job" to each tier, turning them into components of your growth engine.

  • The "Good" Tier (Your Acquisition Engine 🎯): The primary job of your lowest-priced tier is acquisition. It's the on-ramp to your product. It should solve a core, tangible problem for a new user but have clear, logical limitations around your value metric (e.g., number of users, projects, or API calls). The goal isn't to keep users here forever; it's to get them in the door and demonstrate value, making the upgrade to the next tier a natural next step as their needs grow.
  • The "Better" Tier (Your Monetization Engine 💰): This is your core offering and your primary monetizationengine. This tier should be designed and priced specifically for your Ideal Customer Profile (ICP). It should offer the most compelling combination of features and value. In most cases, this is the plan you want the majority of your customers to choose.
  • The "Best" Tier (Your Maximization Engine 🚀): The job of your top tier is maximization. It’s built for your largest, most demanding customers who need advanced functionality like enterprise-grade security, dedicated support, or unlimited scale. But it performs another crucial, psychological job: it serves as a value anchor.


The Psychology of Choice: Anchoring for Growth

Your "Best" tier, even if only a fraction of your customers buy it, is one of your most important sales tools. By pricing it at a significant premium, you anchor the customer's perception of value.


Imagine your tiers are priced at $29, $99, and $499 per month. For a growing business looking for a robust solution, the $499 plan might feel like too much. But next to it, the $99 plan suddenly looks incredibly reasonable—a fantastic deal for all the value it provides. Without the high anchor, that same $99 price point might have felt expensive.


This isn't about tricking your customers. It's about using pricing psychology to guide your ICP to the plan that is truly the best fit for them, creating a win-win scenario.


How to Build Your "Value Fences"

So, how do you decide what goes into each tier? Don't just guess. Use a customer-centric framework like Jobs-to-be-Done (JTBD) to build logical "Value Fences" between your plans.

It’s a simple three-step process:

  1. Map Your ICPs: Who are the distinct segments you serve? For example, a creator platform might serve a "Hobbyist," a "Professional Creator," and a "Media Company."
  2. Define Their Core Job: What is each segment hiring your product to do?
    • The Hobbyist's job is to "publish my ideas easily."
    • The Professional Creator's job is to "grow and monetize my audience."
    • The Media Company's job is to "manage our content empire securely."
  3. Align Features to the Job: Now, group your features based on the job they help complete.
    • Good Tier (Hobbyist): Gets basic publishing tools.
    • Better Tier (Professional): Gets monetization tools, analytics, and custom domains.
    • Best Tier (Media Co.): Gets multi-user collaboration, advanced security (SSO), and dedicated support.


This process creates a clear, logical upgrade path. A Hobbyist who turns professional will naturally need the tools in the next tier up.


From Smart Tiers to Higher Valuation

This isn't just an academic exercise. A well-architected pricing structure is a primary driver of your company's valuation. Here's why:

  • Net Revenue Retention (NRR): The frictionless upgrade path means your revenue grows even if your new customer acquisition is flat. As your customers succeed and grow, they naturally move up your tiers, driving expansion revenue. An NRR above 120% can dramatically increase your valuation multiple.
  • Higher LTV:CAC: By effectively segmenting customers, you maximize the lifetime value (LTV) from each one while your customer acquisition cost (CAC) remains focused.


Your pricing tiers are a product. They need to be designed with the same care and strategic thought as your software. When you get it right, you don't just have a pricing page—you have a sustainable engine for growth.



Ready to Architect Your Tiers?


To help you put this framework into action, we've created a one-page worksheet. It will guide you through the process of mapping your customer segments, their jobs-to-be-done, and the features that define each tier.


➡️ Download our free SaaS Pricing Tier Canvas to architect a structure that drives growth.

If you're ready to go deeper and learn the full strategic framework for monetization, register for our upcoming masterclass.


➡️ Register for the free masterclass, "Pricing is Your Product," and learn how to build a sustainable monetization engine.